Chapter 10 - The Auditor's Missing Pages|

Daniel Cross chose a quiet restaurant on the Upper West Side, far from the financial district where he had spent most of his career.
He was in his late sixties, with silver hair and the careful movements of a man accustomed to handling delicate evidence.
He did not order lunch.
"I won't keep you long," he said. "I no longer have access to my former firm's systems, and I won't speculate beyond what my records support."
"That's all I want."
He opened a slim folder.
"Your father approached me after discovering discrepancies in several investment accounts. He believed funds had been moved through related entities without adequate disclosure."
"Did you confirm that?"
"I confirmed inconsistencies. I did not complete a full audit before your father died."
"Was Preston involved?"
"Mr. Hart contacted me independently. He wanted to understand the structure of Northstar Meridian."
"When?"
"Several months before your father's death."
I stared at him.
"Was he working with my father?"
"Not officially. He was connected to one of the portfolio advisers."
"Did you tell him about your findings?"
"I shared limited information with authorized parties. I cannot disclose every communication without reviewing the original engagement records."
"Do you have those records?"
He nodded.
"Some. My former firm retained the official files, but I kept personal working notes in accordance with the rules that applied at the time."
He removed three pages from the folder.
They contained handwritten observations about discrepancies between reported assets and the underlying account statements.
One entry was underlined.
Possible unauthorized transfer through affiliated holding company. Obtain independent confirmation.
Another read:
Account 17B appears in collateral references despite unclear ownership authority.
I looked up.
"What happened next?"
"Your father asked for a second meeting. He wanted to bring a lawyer. I agreed."
"But he died."
"Yes."
"And Preston?"
"Mr. Hart contacted me afterward. He said the family wanted the investigation closed."
"The family?"
"He referred to a representative who had authority to speak for the Vale estate."
"Victoria?"
"I cannot identify the person from that phrase alone. I did not receive a signed instruction from your father, so I declined to close the matter."
I leaned forward.
"Did Preston try to obtain your notes?"
"Yes."
My throat tightened.
"When?"
"Several years later. He asked whether I had preserved the pages. I told him I had."
"Did he threaten you?"
"No. He was polite. He offered to pay for a consultation. I refused because the proposed engagement was not properly documented."
I studied the pages.
"Can these prove fraud?"
"No. They establish that questions were raised and that certain records deserved further examination. A qualified forensic accountant would need the original transaction data to reach stronger conclusions."
That caution mattered. I did not want a convenient villain. I wanted the truth.
"Can you help us locate the original data?"
"Your attorney can request it through appropriate legal channels. I will provide a sworn statement about the notes I retained."
I thanked him.
As I stood to leave, Daniel closed the folder.
"Caroline, there is one thing I remember clearly."
"What?"
"Your father said he was afraid the investigation would become personal."
"Did he say why?"
"He told me someone close to the family had already tried to persuade him to stop."
"Who?"
"I don't know. But he said the person had access to private trust information."
I felt the familiar chill return.
Victoria had access.
Preston had access.
And someone had copied both Margaret's and my signatures onto a financial document.
That afternoon, Rebecca filed a request for a court-supervised review of the disputed transfer and preservation of the relevant records. She also began the process of seeking recovery of the jewelry through the proper legal channels.
Then Henry called.
"The broker has responded to our inquiry," he said. "He has agreed to preserve the pieces while ownership is investigated."
"Where are they?"
"At a secure vault. I cannot give you the location without the broker's authorization, but your attorney has received the formal notice."
For the first time in days, I allowed myself a breath of relief.
Then Henry continued.
"There's a problem. The broker's paperwork lists a second owner."
"Who?"
"Victoria Vale."
I sat down.
"That isn't possible."
"The paperwork claims she transferred the collection to Preston before he pledged it."
"My aunt never owned those pieces."
"Then the transfer will need to be challenged."
I looked at the auditor's notes.
The disputed authorization.
The missing records.
The account number.
My father's death.
And now Victoria's name on a document claiming ownership of the jewels.
I called my aunt.
She answered in a whisper.
"Caroline, please don't come here."
"Why?"
"Because Preston is already here."
I froze.
"What is he doing at your house?"
Victoria began to cry.
"He says if I don't sign the new statement, he'll tell everyone what I did."
"What did you do?"
She drew a trembling breath.
May you like
Then she said:
"I helped him move the money."