Chapter 6 - What Emma Overheard
Emma Hastings had perfected, over eleven years of life, the particular skill of appearing to be absorbed in her phone or her book while absorbing, in fact, every word of the adult conversation happening one room away. It was a skill she'd developed during the worst months of her parents' separation, when information about her own life had seemed to travel through walls and closed doors rather than directly to her, and she had learned that if she wanted to understand what was actually happening to her family, she would have to listen for it herself.
So when her mother came home from Bellamy's diner and called Michael that evening, voice low but not quite low enough to be inaudible through the thin wall between the kitchen and the den where Emma sat pretending to do homework, Emma heard every word.
"...a DNA test, yes... no, Michael, I'm not trying to make this difficult, I just think the kids deserve clarity before we tell them anything at all... yes, I know it's close to Christmas, that's exactly why I don't want to blindside them with half a story..."
Emma set down her math worksheet and crept to the doorway.
"...I don't know what I feel about her," her mother was saying, quieter now, almost to herself. "I keep thinking about Mom. About every conversation I ever had with her and wondering what was true and what was just — performance. I don't know how to be angry at a dead woman, Michael. There's nowhere to put it."
A long pause. Emma held her breath.
"No," her mother said, "I don't need you to fix it. I just needed to say it out loud to someone who remembers her too."
When Claire hung up, she found Emma standing in the doorway, worksheet forgotten in her hand.
"How much did you hear?" Claire asked, too tired for anything but honesty.
"Enough," Emma said. "Mom — is Sophia actually your sister?"
Claire sat down heavily at the kitchen table, patting the chair beside her. Emma took it, setting the worksheet aside, and waited with the peculiar patience of a child who has learned that adults need time to find their words.
"We think so," Claire said finally. "Grandma Marianne — my mom — had Sophia before she had me. A long time ago, before she married your grandpa. She wasn't able to raise Sophia, so Sophia was adopted by another family, and Grandma never told anyone. Not me, not anyone."
Emma absorbed this with the grave seriousness she brought to most information, turning it over visibly on her face. "That's really sad," she said finally. "For Sophia, I mean. She grew up not knowing she had a whole other family."
"Yes," Claire said, surprised, as she often was, by her daughter's capacity for empathy toward people who complicated her own life. "It is sad."
"Are you mad at Grandma?"
Claire considered lying, softening it for her daughter's sake, and then decided against it. Emma had never responded well to soft lies; she collected them like evidence and produced them later, at inconvenient moments, asking why the story had changed.
"A little," Claire admitted. "I'm mad that she kept it secret. I'm sad that she must have carried it alone for so long. And I'm confused, because I don't know how to feel about a mother I thought I knew completely, finding out there was this whole enormous part of her life I never got to see."
"Is Sophia going to be my aunt now?" Emma asked. "Because that's weird, right? If she marries Dad, she'd be my stepmom and my aunt at the same time."
Despite herself, Claire laughed — a real laugh, surprised out of her by her daughter's blunt, unerring logic. "Yeah, baby. That is objectively pretty weird."
"Jack's going to think it's hilarious," Emma said. "He already thinks Sophia's cool because she let him watch the game with extra ice cream that one time."
"Please don't tell Jack yet," Claire said. "This is grown-up news. I want to figure out how to explain it properly before he hears half of it and builds a whole story around the wrong half."
"Like how I heard half of your phone call and had to ask you what the other half meant?" Emma said, with the particular smugness of a child who has just outmaneuvered a parent.
"Exactly like that," Claire said, tugging her daughter into a hug despite Emma's token protest that she was too old for hugs at the kitchen table on a school night. "You're too smart for your own good, you know that?"
May you like
"Dad says I get that from you," Emma said into her mother's shoulder.
Claire held her daughter a moment longer, thinking of her own mother, of secrets and inheritance, of all the things passed down through blood that had nothing to do with intention — laughter, stubbornness, sharp eyes that noticed too much. She thought of Sophia's dark eyes, so like Emma's own, and wondered, not for the first time since the pageant, how much of what made a family had ever really been about the stories people chose to tell, and how much was simply written into the blood whether anyone chose to say it out loud or not.
