Chapter 3 - The Scholarship with a Stolen Signature

Vincent turned the notebook toward the desk lamp. The copied invoice had a date, a purchase order, and a signature that looked almost like his, except for the upward stroke on the C. His actual signature ended low, the way his father had taught him when Vincent was seventeen and believed a beautiful pen could make ugly work respectable. Someone who knew him had copied the version printed on the foundation's website.
“Where did you see this?” he asked.
“On a clipboard at the warehouse. A guy got mad because the numbers didn't balance. He kept saying the school had to approve it before Thursday.”
“Did you take a photograph?”
Charmian shook her head. “They take our phones at the door. I wrote it down in the bathroom.”
Vincent looked up. “You copied a financial document while people were threatening your life?”
“I'm an accounting student. Numbers are what I notice.” Her voice hardened. “I couldn't stop them from hitting me. I could remember what they were doing.”
That answer unsettled him more than her injuries had. He had spent years mistaking fear for helplessness. Here was a young woman who had been terrified and had still found a way to leave a trail. He reached for his desk phone, then stopped. Aleandro usually handled financial problems. Aleandro had also brought him a suspiciously complete folder on Charmian less than five hours after the warehouse incident came to light.
“Who has access to the foundation's accounts?” she asked.
“My bookkeeper, two trustees, and Aleandro.”
“Then don't call any of them yet.”
Vincent gave her a sharp look. She didn't retreat.
“Someone made a copy of your signature,” she said. “One of those people might know who.”
Instead of placing the call, he asked whether he could photograph the notebook. She agreed, then made him photograph every page, including her notes about times and people. She kept the original. For a man accustomed to being handed whatever he pointed at, it was an unfamiliar arrangement. He accepted it.
He called an attorney named Miriam Chen, who had handled the legitimate side of several Costa businesses and had spent years refusing work that couldn't survive daylight. When he told her a nineteen-year-old employee had been threatened over a relative's debt, Miriam's first question wasn't how much money was involved.
“Does she have independent counsel?”
Vincent stared at the phone. “No.”
“Then get her one. Not someone I select. Someone she chooses. You are her employer, and you have conflicts all over this situation.”
Charmian, listening from across the desk, raised one eyebrow. “I like her.”
“So do I,” Vincent said, sounding as though he resented it.
Miriam gave Charmian the number for a local victims' advocacy office with legal referrals. She also urged her to seek medical care, preserve communications, and make a report through a channel where her statement could be documented. Charmian wrote everything down. She wanted time to decide which steps to take. Miriam told Vincent not to mistake that time for permission to investigate her private life again.
Mrs. Gable appeared at the office doorway carrying fresh linens. The head housekeeper, a stout woman in her sixties with kind eyes, took one look at Charmian's face and set the basket down. “Child, I asked you to clean the kitchen yesterday afternoon. I did not ask you to work all night.”
“I know,” Charmian said.
“Then why didn't you wake me?”
“Because you might have tried to help.”
Mrs. Gable's mouth trembled. She looked away, not offended, but frightened by the answer. She had worked at the estate for twenty years and had learned to keep the staff's troubles outside the main rooms. Today that habit felt very small.
Vincent asked whether Charmian wanted transportation to urgent care. She requested a taxi instead of one of his drivers. He paid for it as an employer covering a workplace medical concern, and Mrs. Gable accompanied her because Charmian asked. At the clinic, a physician cleaned and dressed her knuckles, examined the injuries on her face and leg, and asked whether she felt safe returning home. Charmian described the threats without pretending the Costa estate was a normal workplace. The physician documented what she observed and offered resources. She didn't insist Charmian make every decision before leaving the exam room.
On the taxi ride back, Charmian stared at the low gray sky. Mrs. Gable sat beside her, holding a paper bag of crackers she had bought at the clinic vending machine.
“When my husband drank,” Mrs. Gable said at last, “I used to tell everybody I was clumsy. The first person who helped me didn't ask why I hadn't left sooner. She asked which bus I wanted to take.”
Charmian looked at her. “Did you leave?”
“Eventually. Took me three tries.”
They rode the rest of the way without speaking. Before the gates, Charmian asked the driver to take her to campus instead. She needed to speak to her professor. Mrs. Gable didn't argue. She went inside with her, waiting near the library while Charmian climbed two flights of stairs to the business department.
Professor Naomi Reed was eating a cold sandwich over a pile of exam booklets when Charmian knocked. Her expression shifted from irritation to concern the moment she saw her student. “Charmian? I've been trying to reach you.”
“My phone's been off.”
“I noticed. Sit down.”
Charmian explained that she'd been threatened and forced to miss classes. She didn't name the Costa foundation yet. She showed the clinic discharge papers and asked whether a deferred midterm was possible. Professor Reed listened, then opened the college's student-support portal. “There are procedures for emergencies. We'll follow them. Your grades don't vanish because someone harmed you.”
For the first time in days, Charmian felt something release beneath her ribs. “I thought you'd say I should've called.”
“I wish you could have,” Reed said. “That's not the same thing.”
The professor started an appointment request with the student-support office. Then she frowned at her monitor. “Wait. Why does your record say withdrawn?”
Charmian leaned across the desk. “What?”
“Your enrollment ended yesterday. It says you requested a voluntary withdrawal, including cancellation of your scholarship.”
“I didn't.”
Reed opened the attached request. A digital signature appeared beside Charmian's name. The letter said she no longer wished to pursue higher education and requested that any remaining tuition credit be returned to the funding organization.
Charmian recognized the exact phrase on the warehouse invoices: funding organization.
Professor Reed turned the screen toward her. “Is that your signature?”
“No.”
At the bottom of the form was a witness name.
Aleandro White.
May you like
Charmian photographed the screen with trembling hands. Then she called Vincent.
“Your underboss didn't just know I missed class,” she said when he answered. “He signed the form that took me out of it.”